U.RAT Key Learnings

Here are some key design notes and learnings:

  1. I had to use a Raspberry Pi due to the fact that the KPOD driver software is written in C and compiled on Linux.
  2. The KPOD is a proprietary device using the HIDRAW protocol, so its not exactly the same as a keyboard or mouse
  3. The WiringPi library turns the interfacing part between software and pin outs on the RaspberryPi into basically a “virtual Arduino”. This makes it amazingly simple to use the Raspi GPIO interface / pins
  4. I do not need the Enable positive or negative lines from the TB6600 drivers
  5. The TB6600 drivers are probably overkill, but they represent good engineering and stay cool no matter what
  6. The delay in the program and the DIP switches on the drivers are what set the steppers in the right “zone” as far as response from the KPOD. The DIP switches are – (1 – 6): U,D,D,D,U,U
  7. The wiring of the drivers is very easy – all grounds are ganged, and the 3.3 and 5V grounds are tied together – meaning one ground wire for everything is all that is needed. Then, only two wires are needed from the drivers – one for direction (DIR) and one for step (PUL).
  8. I’m splitting the system in two – drivers and steppers out at the tuner and everything else in the shack. Since I will use a 12v to 5V regulated and filtered step down gizmo to supply 5V to the Raspi off of a 12V supply, the 5V stays in the shack and 12v goes out to the tuner. This means 12V + and – wires and 4 wires for the drivers total. Add in two wires for the kill switches and you get exactly 8 wires needed from the control box in the shack to the tuner box
  9. The Palstar BT1500A is a truly amazing balanced line tuner. It offers pretty much every configurable setting for all low bands with an antenna that is resonant on 160M but used also on 80, 40 and 30. Since the SPE Expert 1.3K FA amplifier requires a low SWR, the Palstar tuner is exactly the right tuner. I did remember to bypass the SPE internal ATU for 160, 80 and 30M, which are the bands the Mod Bob and Palstar will be used on. I do use the ATU in the SPE on my DXE 40M phased array and my 20M homebrew 2 element yagi
  10. The Mod Bob is the most amazing low band antenna I have used because it covers low bands with very respectable performance – and this is the “holy grail” of antennas. I never expected to finally get a bastardized Bobtail Curtain to work so well. I tried feeding Bobtails twice before against ground and they seemed no better than a single vertical. HOWEVER, this open wire balanced line fed antenna models great and plays better than expected. Sure – a dipole up a half wave, but I can only get a dipole 1/2 wl on 30M, so I’d have a cloud warmer on all of the lower bands. This is where what I read on Tom, W8JI’s web site has to be put in context. Yes, I would always choose one or more elements up 1/2 wl over any vertical, but, to do what I have done on the low bands (and given my crappy terrain down here in the bowl), I truly believe I have conquered the problem with flying colors
  11. The URAT consumes .75 amps with no load – once I have the variable capacitor and the roller inductor added, I will be able to see the current draw with my variable bench supply. Now I see why a variable bench supply is so important – besides setting current limiting on the stepper drivers (so you don’t burn the drivers up or run them over heated), you can protect what you plug into the supply voltage and current wise. Then, you can monitor how much current the steppers are drawing under load and not under load
  12. The Raspberry Pi Zero W plus Adafruit Pi-OLED is the absolute perfect device for the processor part of this project – small and has exactly what you need – not a thing more. A VERY elegant design
  13.  The KPOD can be marketed to the much larger Maker community. It is a wonderful ham radio shack automation controller – and its applications above and beyond the URAT seem only limited by your imagination
  14. I think I am having the most fun I have ever had in electronics and ham radio. This Maker World has expanded my world so far past just sitting in the shack waiting for the next ATNO that its not even funny. I feel like I used to just be an ATNO junkie . . . “Hands on Ham Radio” is my rehab. To be fair – building antennas used to be my rehab – but I’ve run the gamut on that
  15. I won’t be working on any more DX-peditions, but will instead be making stuff in my shack / lab
  16. I feel that just doing my first Maker project that its as important as Honor Roll and DX-pedition of the Year. I don’t know why – this is totally an emotional response
  17. If the steppers don’t draw more than twice what they under no load, it might have been possible to use the Adafruit Pi Hat Motor Shield – which is rated at 1.2 amps per stepper, HOWEVER, because the drivers will go out with the steppers in the tuner box – the Adafruit hat doesn’t work for this configuration. For another project it will be perfect – perhaps with the Nema 17 steppers I have – since they are lighter duty but still quite strong. I felt the NEMA 23’s were best for the torque needed for the L and C components
  18. When I explained the difference between the Raspberry Pi and Arduino, she asked “Why would you even bother with the Arduino?” That’s a very good question, since the Raspi Zero W costs only $26 and the Arduino – $18.82 (official units not cheap knock offs)
  19. Writing code for embedded devices is just too much fun – and my C and Python background were both very important. Also – having been an Oracle DBA on UNIX and Linux meant that I had no learning curve with what might be the most technical part of the project. The electronics part is about 8th grade science fair level – the software part a little higher – but kids these days take to this stuff very quickly – don’t underestimate them. Great memories of 1971 building my first Heathkit come rushing back
  20. I feel like I can be a product designer now – its an awesome feeling – like I can do anything

So – how much is this experience worth in dollars?

3 Comments on “U.RAT Key Learnings

  1. I think the cheap knockoffs ARE one of the key points of the Arduino. I can get a pretty reasonable-quality knockoff board for under $3, and I can also buy an official Atmega 328P chip for $1.95 on Mouser, single quantity. All I need to get a fully functional embedded Arduino from that is to add a 20 cent crystal and a couple of capacitors and resistors. If I want to keep costs low and builds simple, that’s hard to beat. Using all reliable parts from reliable distributors, I have an embedded MCU in my project for less than $2.50. And power consumption is going to be way lower too. I’d choose the Pi if I wanted raw CPU power and easy extensibility and programmability. I’d choose the Arduino if I wanted cheap, simple, robust, low-power, and real-time. So there you are… apples and oranges really. Glad you’re enjoying yourself!

    Like

    • Of course – your time is worth your hourly rate at work. So there is a cost . . .

      But its all depends on your use case.

      Even the full on “official” boards are dirt cheap considering what you can do with them.

      Like

      • If you’re making one, sure, the cost of your time may be a major factor. If you want to make kits, or go to manufacturing, it’s a different story. Also, I don’t think I’m much slower programming the Arduino. As with everything, YMMV.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: